New proposed EU law will gut the protections for birds, potentially impacting 170 bird species and other protected wildlife
Data Centres will also be fast tracked.
It looks like politicians and some big industry lobbyists are getting fed up with having to protect birds, whales, dolphins, bats and wildflowers. Instead of prioritizing nature and our communities like some have said they would, our wildlife is now being portrayed as an obstacle to infrastructure.
This proposed law will gut the protections for birds potentially impacting 170 bird species1. These include:
- 38 Red Listed species like Barn Owl, Swift, Curlew, Lapwing, Stock Dove, Yellowhammer, Kestrel and more
- 54 Amber Listed species including Mute Swan, Mallard, Wigeon, Cormorant, Shag, Gannet, Skylark, House Martin and more
- 78 Green Listed species including Brent Goose, Sparrowhawk, Buzzard, Long-eared Owl and more
This law is called the Regulation on Speeding Up Environmental Assessments (RSEA).
The new law would make it easier to kill birds and if the member states and European Commission get their way it would also fast track data centres.
————————————————————————————————————–
Environmental Impact Assessment is a good thing but it’s under attack
Environmental impact assessment of plans and projects is important. It is about good planning, reviewing and assessing the impacts of a project on water, wildlife, habitats and making sure that citizens have a right to properly consider new developments which could affect their lives. These could be roads, housing developments, airports, data centres, chemical plants and many more developments. They assess impacts on air and water quality, human health and the impact to wildlife. Environmental assessment legislation been around for a long time and is derived from an EU EIA Directive.
However, environmental assessment is now being blamed for slow delivery of infrastructure. So governments, lobbyists and the European Commission want to change the law. We believe that there are many gaps and issues with the way laws are already implemented and we’ve listed our thoughts here 2 with some suggestions on how to make things better.
New environmental assessment rules remove protections for birds and other wildlife
The RSEA originated with the European Commission with its proposed legal text published in 2025. EU member state governments gave their agreed review of the RSEA on September 30th 2026. On November 4th the ENVI committee of the European Parliament considered the legislation and voted in their own view of the legislation. On November 24th 2026 the full European Parliament of elected members (MEPs) including Irish MEPs will vote on this text (note: new amendments may be proposed for the vote).
Article 8 of this text would fundamentally change the strict legal protection that currently exists for birds when plans and projects have to go through environmental assessment. At the moment all wild birds are protected and deliberate killing is illegal as is the destruction of eggs, nests and disturbance to them. You actually need a license kill a bird and to derogate from this system of protection.
The proposed new law would allow deliberate killing of birds, destruction of eggs and nests and disturbance to birds when implementing a plan or when constructing, operating or decommissioning a development. And the same would apply to protected wildlife like otters, bats, our one protected insect – the Marsh Fritillary butterfly, whales, dolphins and protected plants.
The ENVI committee added text that mitigation is required to avoid significant adverse impacts and that monitoring is required of mitigation effectiveness to ensure no significant adverse impacts on the favourable conservation status of species. But this wont be enough to stop impacts to wildlife.
Reliance on mitigation will not protect species from this law change
The reliance on mitigation is really problematic. Staff at BirdWatch Ireland have been reviewing and commenting on planning applications for 20 years and often we see mitigation measures that are put forward by developers but rarely is their evidence to prove that they work and still we see the conclusions of environmental assessments that there will be no significant adverse impacts.
There’s already a lot of problems with existing environmental assessment and many bird species are still declining as a result. For example, we once saw signage as the proposed mitigation for the impacts of dogs on the sensitive waterbirds in an estuary. No evidence was provided that signage would work. In fact many would say that in Ireland signs are often ignored.
The results from monitoring will come too late for some species
The reliance on monitoring of the proposed mitigation to see if there will be adverse impacts on a population after the development is built/put in place is also terrible. In Ireland population level impacts to bird species might not be determined for a number of years and then it is highly likely that it will be too late. Populations don’t just bounce back easily with quick fixes. It can take decades and sometimes it’s impossible. Many species are faithful to nesting sites and come back year after year (think of Swallows where generations keep returning) and if the sites are gone, they wont be back.
Also, it is proposed that in light of the information gathered during monitoring further measures might be required to remedy problems to ensure favourable conservation status of the species. Favourable conservation status means broadly that populations of a species are healthy. What if it’s too late for further measures? What if a species is already in unfavourable conservation status at the beginning of the assessment at project planning stage? Will they tip over the edge and go extinct in an area before it’s picked up by monitoring?
Regarding monitoring which is already usually required in environmental assessments, BirdWatch Ireland staff have never seen a published a post-construction monitoring report of a development. If they are done they are rarely published online. I once asked a local authority if I could access a post-construction monitoring report for the effects on the Hen Harrier from a wind farm in a Special Protection Area and I was quoted €100 to see the report. Even if you’ve sent a submission as part of the planning process there’s no follow up by the regulatory authorities to keep you in the loop on issues that might have arisen. Often its up to a member of the public to flag an issue.
Parliament suggests cumulative impacts should be assessed
When considering this legislation, the ENVI committee of the European Parliament, did include text to require that cumulative impacts to be assessed. In fact environmental assessment legislation already requires cumulative impacts to be assessed and we believe that this is where many assessments currently fall down. The scale of the human activities and their effects on wildlife is such that many species cannot adapt fast enough and are dying off. It is death by a thousand cuts.
Inclusion of a list of sectors to be fast tracked
Article 14 in the RSEA on includes a long list of sectors which would be given species. The question I ask is what’s not in here. These sectors would be allowed bypass some of the rules covering the most protected sites in the country -our Special Areas of Conservation and our Special Protection Areas for birds. This will lead to further significant impacts on wildlife and habitats. The list of strategic sectors for fast track through the Habitats Directive assessment that the Parliament will vote on (though other amendments might arise before Nov 24) is:
- data centres deployed in data centre acceleration zones
- maritime and inland ports and port-related infrastructure, and inland waterways
- airports and airport-related infrastructure
- railways and railway-related infrastructure, in particular high-speed rail
- net-zero strategic projects
- strategic critical raw material projects
- construction of EuroHPC supercomputer facilities, AI factories, and giga factories
- projects for the prevention, separate collection, re-use, preparing for re-use, and recycling
- new residential dwellings and the renovation of existing residential dwellings, as well as the infrastructure that serves those residential dwellings, including transport, energy, water including wastewater, telecommunications and social infrastructure (i.e., everything to do with housing)
- European semiconductor technology initiatives
- projects identified on the military mobility corridors
- Projects for national defence and corresponding projects of allied partners, including defence-critical projects for the production of arms, munitions and war material
Current system of protection for birds in Ireland
Article 5 of the Birds Directive requires that governments set up a legal framework for the general system of protection for birds. This is the article that bans deliberate killing, destruction of nests/eggs, disturbance. Unfortunately, Ireland has allowed exemptions to this general system of protection for years. These exemptions are contained in Section 22 of the Wildlife Act (as amended). These exemptions are a breach of the Birds Directive and we have been calling on government since 2016 to bring the Irish law in line with EU law. Under Minister Malcolm Noonan the process of reviewing the Wildlife Act began and is ongoing with no recent update.
The exemptions allow the destruction of birds nests and eggs and deliberate killing during building construction as well as roads development but there are other general exemptions relating to agriculture, forestry and fisheries that are in breach also.
Example of how this could play out for the Swift
The Swift is a migratory bird that comes from West Africa and nests in holes in buildings in Ireland and across Europe. We produced a publication on Saving Swifts and do Swift surveys in each county. Swift Conservation Ireland have also been doing really great work for this species. Swifts have seen a precipitous decline and are Red Listed. We have been working to remove the exemption in the Wildlife Act where it is not deliberate to kill a bird in construction works in order to help Swifts. We have seen many cases of loss of Swift nesting sites in buildings due to refurbishment works and it is really concerning. We are also very concerned about the scale retrofitting and further losses of nest sites. Swifts don’t readily adopt new forms of nesting location. The first preference is always to retain their original nest sites before considering a nest brick or nest box.
Good environmental impact assessment should include bird surveys and desk-based review of the species recorded in an area historically so birds like Swifts that nest in a building would be picked up. Often works would be delayed till after the breeding period or would avoid the winter period when migratory waterbirds might be present. Now, save for the mitigation measures proposed, the future looks perilous for birds as their killing would be allowed as would be the destruction of nests and eggs and disturbance. So the birds can be surveyed, identified, mitigation subject to opinion of the ecologist and developer could be proposed, but even with all of that it will be legal if nests are destroyed and birds are killed. What would the motivation be to protect species and provide effective mitigation if the killing of birds is still ok?
The Irish government failed system of protection for birds could become the norm. Is it any wonder that 63% of Ireland’s bird species are threatened.
Proposed changes and impacts to birds
We have calculated that 170 bird species would be impacted by Article 8 and even more impacted as a result of Article 14 as these projects would be allowed to destroy Natura sites which have habitats for birds. These are:
- 38 Red Listed species like Barn Owl, Swift, Curlew, Lapwing, Stock Dove, Yellowhammer, Kestrel and more
- 54 Amber Listed species including Mute Swan, Mallard, Wigeon, Cormorant, Shag, Gannet, Skylark, House Martin and more
- 78 Green Listed species including Brent Goose, Sparrowhawk, Buzzard, Long-eared Owl and more
Even though Ireland already has damaging exemptions, the scale of the proposed legal changes would apply to all developments requiring environmental assessment. The scale of potential damage is staggering.
When we write that 170 bird species would be impacted, we don’t mean that they would be impacted all at once or all in one place where a development is occurring. We mean that over time these species will be negatively impacted by this legislation as their basic legal protections will be gone when it comes to development.
Other current and in-train legislation which will impact birds and wildlife
It’s important to note that this is not the only thing that will negatively impact birds and other wildlife. Pesticides also impact bird species especially Swifts, Swallows and House Martins (also known as aerial insectivores) due to their reliance on insects. Also at EU level and this push for de-regulation is a proposal to weaken the pesticide regulatory system. The organisation advocating on Parkinson’s disease in Europe, Parkinson’s Europe, has come out wholly against this due to the links between pesticides and this terrible disease. In addition, a Financial Times article highlighted the influence of pesticide companies in watering down pesticide legislation.
Pesticides Action Network are working hard on this.
Recall also that the Irish government has weakened the potential for people to take judicial reviews on legislation and has just decided that housing developments of less than 250 units would not require Environmental Impact Assessment.
No new funding for nature restoration and cuts to CAP funding
Coupled with the damaging legislation that is in train, there’s very little new funding to support habitats and wildlife. There was only a €6 million increase in Ireland’s 2027 budget to fund NPWS – THE key Irish government body focused on the coordination of national action for nature in Ireland. There was zero funding for new nature restoration funding either in budget 2027 but hopefully Minister O’Sullivan can still address this. He has said he’s working on a plan.
The EU Common Agriculture Policy provides a lot of funding to farmers for agri-environment schemes and because there’s a proposed 20% cut in funding to the next CAP budget, it could mean less funding for nature and climate too. Farmers own most of the land in Ireland and are absolutely essential to the protection and restoration of habitats for birds and other wildlife. And many are doing really great work already and need this funding support for nature activities.
More bad news: Proposed Review of the Birds and Habitats Directives
Along with all of the above in train at the moment, the European Commission recently added a review of the Birds and Habitats Directives to 2027 Work Programme of the European Commission. Here are the letters we sent Irish ministers including Minister O’Sullivan, Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Commissioner Michael McGrath.
In 2015 a Fitness Check of the Birds and Habitats Directives was launched. It was an evaluation of these laws to see if they were still fit for purpose. They were found to be fit for purpose but that better implementation was required. Member states and the European Commission have not taken this seriously and it’s clear now that they want to weaken rules that protect birds and other wildlife and habitats to avoid having to implement them.
Please help us.
We are fighting so many battles for Ireland’s birds and it is getting harder and harder to save them with so many big lobbyists fighting wanting weaker laws.
Please consider becoming a member of BirdWatch Ireland or
Donate to the BirdWatch Ireland’s Restore Nature appeal.
We need your help more than ever. Thank you.
More background info on the origins of the RSEA and the process
On foot of the Draghi report on competitiveness and statements that the EU was falling behind China and America, in December 2025 the European Commission published proposals to reduce the administrative burden of environmental regulation3. One of the proposals is a regulation to change the environmental assessment process of projects going through the planning process. It was framed as a way to speed up environmental assessments. But in that text was a proposed weakening of the existing laws protecting birds and other protected wildlife when it comes to environmental assessment of plans and projects. So the message is to speed up project approvals, remove the protections for wildlife.
The Irish government took over the Presidency of the European Council on July 1st 2026 and it was up to them to make progress on the speeding up of environmental assessments regulation. They prepared draft text and circulated to other EU governments and that text was finalised and agreed at the end of September. The resulting draft legal text contains very concerning proposals in Article 8 and 144. Some other articles we actually support like Articles 3 and 12.
After the Parliament votes on November 24th, it is likely that the Trilogues will begin. This is the discussion between the Parliament, the Commission and Member State governments in the European Council. After that the legislation will come into force and we hope without these very significant changes which will affect bird populations and other wildlife.
